Pörkölt, the Stew Formerly Known as Goulash, Budapest, Hungary

Pörkölt Recipe, the Stew Formerly Known as Goulash

What I knew about Hungarian food and wine before I first visited Budapest was limited to Bull’s Blood red wine, Tokaji sweet wine, salami, paprika, and the dish that was made using paprika – goulash.

Given that I’ve been stewing and braising away this year – making everything from the bredie in Cape Town, French Cassoulet, Spanish Oxtail Stew, and Moroccan Lamb Tagine with Prunes and Almonds, coupled with the fact that fluffy flakes of snow were starting to swirl around the courtyard of our gorgeous building, goulash appeared to be the perfect dish to make for The Dish.

There was only one problem. Goulash didn’t turn out to be the dish I thought it was. Anyone with even the slightest interest in what’s on their plate at meal time has heard of ‘Hungarian Goulash’, but the dish doesn’t really exist – at least not in the form people who can’t speak Magyar (the notoriously difficult Hungarian language) think.

Goulash (gulyás) is actually soup and gulyás means ‘herdsman’. The dish that most people are thinking of when they imagine ‘Hungarian Goulash’ is a stew with a similar flavour to the soup called pörkölt. While gulyás is made exclusively from beef, pörkölt can be made with other meats.

So when you go to that Hungarian restaurant and you order gulyás and get a stew, that’s the waiter recognizing that you’re a foreigner and assuming that you don’t actually want the soup, but the stew. While he’s being kind, it’s not really helpful because it’s keeping the myth alive. Some menus we saw in Budapest listed gulyás as ‘goulash (soup)’, which goes part of the way to helping clarify the issue.

Every gulyás or pörkölt we tried did have one thing in common, they were absolutely delicious. At the Christmas Markets, in fine dining restaurants, and at old favourites, the smoky earthiness of the paprika is what sets these dishes apart from other stews and soups.

Given the number of stews I’ve made this year, I decided to stick to making pörkölt. Although as food writer Carolyn Bánfalvi (with whom we did a Markets Walk) says in her excellent Food Wine Budapesttome, pörkölt is essentially gulyás without the broth. Both are classic but humble dishes, that are famous not for their complexity in cooking, but for the incredible flavour and hearty texture. If you’re in Budapest and it’s snowing outside, pörkölt or gulyás with a glass of red is the perfect winter meal.

One of the reasons the dish is so humble is that there are so few ingredients. In the book, Cuisine of Hungary by George Lang (one that Carolyn recommended to me as a favourite), the ingredients are listed as veal, lard, onion, paprika, garlic, salt, tomatoes, and green pepper. And the garlic is optional! However, there are a couple of secrets to this dish…

Firstly, the paprika must be Hungarian and fresh – not from the back of the cupboard with a use-by date of 1996. We skipped the fancy displays at the market and bought some from the supermarket – less romantic but more practical as it’s actually more likely to be fresh, the busy supermarket having a higher turnover than the tourist displays in the market. Paprika is one edible take-home that’s essential if you love to cook. We could easily write a feature story just on Hungarian paprika, as it comes in different heat levels, flavours (sweat, spicy), grinds, and colours. We like it hot, so I used a hot Csemege paprika. Although Édesnemes paprika is more common for stews, it’s a little light for me.

The second secret to the dish is that, as you can see from the ingredients above, there is no stock used, nor wine, or flour. Even if you’re making gulyás, it’s water that is added. The ‘gravy’ for this dish comes from the onion and the meat – although you add a little water to stop things sticking occasionally.

Although not strictly sticking to the letter of the pörkölt lore, I like to add carrots and potatoes – both additions that are fine for gulyás. With pörkölt, potatoes are usually served on the side but I’ve never been a fan of plain boiled potatoes when they could be enhanced by a dip in the stew. Many people also serve it with dumplings, but seriously, while it helps to make a balanced meal by providing carbohydrates, unless you are an actual herdsman who has done a day’s slog, you might find this to be too filling. I just like serving it with some decent bread. Carolyn serves it with polenta or spätzle (egg noodle) and tells me that Budapest locals like to eat it with “pickled vegetables, and some hot paprika on the table so everyone can add as much (or little) heat as they like.”

If some guests find your version too hot, sour cream is your friend. Leave it in a dish on the table. If there is a Hungarian at the table they will now point out that the dish is now best called beef paprikás. If you added some wine during cooking instead of water (I won’t tell anyone, it is delicious), you’ll be informed the dish is called pincepörkölt or ‘cellar stew’.

Whatever you call it, just don’t call it goulash, okay?

4.0 from 2 reviews
Pörkölt (Hungarian Stew)
Pörkölt is a classic but humble stew, famous for the incredible flavour and hearty texture. It's not goulash, that's a soup.
Cuisine: Hungarian
Recipe type: Main
Serves: 4
Prep time: 
Cook time: 
Total time: 
  • Ingredients
  • 1 kilo stewing beef cut into one inch dice
  • 2 tablespoons lard (I used rendered fat from a big block of delicious bacon)
  • 1 onion, minced
  • 1 tablespoon paprika
  • 1 garlic clove, mashed
  • 1 generous teaspoon salt (you can add more later if necessary)
  • 1 small tin of peeled tomatoes
  • 1 green pepper, chopped finely
  • 4 potatoes, quartered
  • 4 carrots, sliced
  1. Cook the onions in lard in a Dutch oven or casserole dish until lightly browned regardless. (Instead of lard, the diet-conscious could use some kind of neutral oil to cook the onions in but that would be a shame.)
  2. Take off the heat and add the paprika and garlic and stir through.
  3. Add the meat and salt and, over a lowish flame, stir until the meat starts to colour. If the meat starts to stick, add a little water.
  4. When the meat is browned, add the tomato and pepper and keep stirring.
  5. By now you should have enough liquid to leave the dish almost unattended, leaving you free to fend off hungry householders. And neighbours. The aroma is amazing.
  6. Every 10 minutes or so, check the dish and add more liquid as required, but just enough to stop it from burning.
  7. Cooking time should be around two to three hours.
  8. Par cook the carrots and potatoes in salted water and drain. Add just before serving.
  9. Serve with a decent bottle of red.
Nutrition Information
Serving size: 1 Calories: 569 Fat: 11.9g Saturated fat: 2.6g Unsaturated fat: 9.3 Trans fat: 0g Carbohydrates: 50.8g Sugar: 12.4g Sodium: 177mg Fiber: 8.4g Protein: 62.4g Cholesterol: 6mg


There are 8 comments

Add yours
  1. Dwight

    Very interesting and well-written article. I am a little leery of the cooking technique. How does it not burn with so little water after two to three hours?

  2. Terence Carter

    Dwight, “Every 10 minutes or so, check the dish and add more liquid as required, but just enough to stop it from burning.” You want a thick sauce with this, hence the minimal amount of water.

  3. Attila

    Thank you for steering people away from the common misconception of what ghoulash is.
    Both gulyás and pörkölt have the same “base”, the meat and paprika, but there is a key ingredient in gulyás what you won’t find in pörkölt, the caraway.
    Pörkölt is not a dish on its own but a way you cook the meat, so it naturally goes with some sides like dumplings, noodles or potato, plus some pickles.
    Gulyás on the other hand is a very rich soup, it can even be a dish on its own.
    They are also different not only in the amount of water we use to cook them (in the pörkölt we use it only to prevent paprika from getting bitter), but in their ingredients: most importantly the caraway, and if you prepare gulyás as a single dish, it “contains” the carrot and potato, we cook them together, not serve them as side.

  4. Lara Dunston

    Thank you – and thank you for the further clarification and tips. Much appreciated. We didn’t end up doing a cooking class in Budapest as we normally would, so we were really only talking to local experts and doing our own research. We’re so pleased you’ve provided this here and hope you don’t mind if we incorporate it into the post above. It drives us a little crazy when the same incorrect information and myths are perpetuated – not just with Hungarian cuisine, but with all cuisines – can’t tell you how many people get things wrong when it comes to Southeast Asian cuisines and the same mistakes just keep getting written up time and time again. A lot of copying goes on unfortunately. Thanks for taking the time to leave a comment.

Post a new comment

Rate this recipe: